Winmark Corporation
Winmark Corporation franchises retail store concepts that buy, sell, and trade merchandise. It operates middle-market equipment leasing and buys/sells used goods through various brands: Platos Closet (teen/young adult), Once Upon A Child (childrens items), Play It Again Sports (sporting goods), Style Encore (womens apparel), and Music Go Round (musical instruments).
Overview
Strengths
- Shows the financial signature of a durable competitive advantage (economic moat): consistently high returns on capital, returns well above its cost of capital, an asset-light, cash-generative model, high, stable gross margins (pricing power) and operating margins that held up every year.
- Return on invested capital has stayed above 15% in each of the last 6 years (latest 100.0%), a hallmark of a durable competitive advantage.
- Creates economic value: ROIC of 100.0% against a cost of capital (WACC) of 6.7%, a spread of 93.3 percentage points.
- Pricing power: gross margin has held between 93% and 96% over the last 6 years (latest 96.4%).
- Asset-light, cash-generative model: capital expenditure takes only 1.9% of revenue and free cash flow was positive in each of the last 6 years.
- EBITDA margin of 67.6% beats 100% of its 19 Specialty Retail peers (median 12.6%).
Weaknesses
- Our discounted cash flow target price (210.24 USD) is 22% below the current price.
- Valued at a premium to its Specialty Retail peers: P/FCF 21.5x vs. a median of 9.6x and EV/EBITDA 17.9x vs. a median of 8.4x.
Key Financial Data